Welcome to the Historic Columbus Indiana Website!

 

A Decade Of Baseball

with the Columbus Merchants

by Julian Piercefield

Home Page

About The Historic Columbus Indiana Website

Bartholomew County Directory 1903 -- 1904

Bill Stearman

Columbus Indiana: A Day In The Life...

Columbus Indiana: Downtown Pictures 1966

Columbus Indiana Fire Department

Columbus Indiana Picture Collections

Columbus Indiana Historic Postcards

Columbus High School Yearbooks and Logs 1916 --1970

Columbus Merchants Baseball Team

Cummins Bookstore History

Crump Theatre History

Historic Columbus Indiana Site Map

I Discover Columbus, by Will Marsh

Illustrated Columbus Indiana 1914 -- 1915

John Crump: Columbus Indiana Pioneer

Links to other Columbus Indiana-related sites

MESSAGE BOARD!

Old Historic Columbus Indiana Website

Schwartzkopf Opera House

What Columbus Indiana Watched on Television

Write to me

    

  

Click on the picture to go to the next page!

    

    

    

 

[Page 45]     [Page 47]

 

 

" FOUL BALL "

As a change... and to fill an unexpected space in this booklet, I shall relate here, an amusing story about two of these Merchant players.

A Merchant pitcher.. . let's call him "Harry" and one of the catchers on the team, let's call him "Stan", were approached by representatives Edinburg team one fall in the '50s. This was after the Merchant's season had ended. Most Columbus players were back tin college.

It seems that the Edinburg team had an annual "grudge" game with the Franklin nine. This was to be an important tie breaking game of their series...for the braggin' rights of Johnson County. Both teams really wanted to win. Harry was offered a fee of $20, to pitch for the Edinburg team. And, if he were to win the game an added bonus of $20 would be his. To aid Harry, they invited Stan, with a fee of $20 to be paid to him for the game. They agreed !

And so, on a pleasant fall afternoon, game time rapidly approached, but all was not well ! The umpiring crew (especially hired out of Indianapolis) had not arrived. Finally, 10 minutes after the posted game time, the Managers agreed to start the game with the only known and willing person with any umpiring experience. This person could have been properly called. . "an old codger". He was complete; overalls, clod-hoppers and a slouched hat... to go with a physical appearance that would leave one to wonder if he had two bottles of wine for breakfast. He worked from behind the pitcher's mound. Through one complete inning he did quite well!

The errant Indy umps arrived with two out in the bottom of the first inning. They took over beginning with the start of the second inning. Both of the Managers agreed to put the "Old Codger" at third base to finish the game. Who could get in trouble there?

It was the top of the fourth inning, score 0 to 0, with Franklin at bat. After one out, there was a single and then Harry walked a man. This was the first scoring opportunity in the game. Some pressure was developing. With a count of 2 and 2, Franklin's next batter (perhaps their best) turned on an inside curve ball and screamed it deep down the left field foul line ! ! The old codger, turned, moved a few steps down the line (represented by a faded, semi-straight old line of lime) and emphatically called .... "Fair Ball"!!! [Ed: Stan later said he thought it was a foot fair.) W-e-l-l, base runners and errant throws flew about! ! ! And after the dust had cleared, two runners had scored and the batter was now perched at third base. WOW - a big change!

Stan could see that Harry was upset by these turn of events and a meeting at the mound confirmed this. Some time was needed for Harry to regain his composure. So Stan said, "Let me check something"! Thereupon he casually walked over to third base and in effect said to the old codger, "Say, you were not supposed to make that call, the home plate umpire has the better alignment, what with the bag and the foul pole". The old codger came right back with . . "I didn't hear him make the call"!. . To which Stan retorted, "Well, I heard him call Foul Ball !! ! You guys better get your stories straight." (Stan later reports that he did, indeed, hear "Foul Ball". But suspects it was someone behind the backstop screen.)

The umpire then walked to home plate where a conference was held. The Indy base umpire soon joined the pair, and suddenly the men in blue began shouting and waving their arm... ."Foul Ball". Runners were to return to their respective bases and our hero was to again take his place at the plate with a count of 2 and 2 ! !

           Well, then all H__! Broke loose. There begins the biggest, loudest argument and name calling - brou- ha-ha seen in many of years. There was screaming and yelling and a couple of near scuffles with no reason in site. As both benches cleared, Harry and Stan quietly adjourned to the bench to take it all in. Stan chuckled, "I guess I woke everybody up!"

Near fights (with bats !) were fortunately quelled and after about 10 minutes of this the lead umpire stated, "We start again in 5 minutes!". As Harry and Stan began to warm up again, their attention was directed to the Franklin bench where... the Franklin team was gathering up their equipment and with a few choice expletives.... they left to go home!!!

Harry and Stan continued their laugh. Then, suddenly, Stan blurted, "Harry! No game! !! We don't get paid ! ! ! And $20 was some neat date money in those '50s! Both still enjoy relating this story... and Stan hadn't even argued the call, merely commented about protocol !!!